Skip to main content

(414) 276-2850

NEW PUBLISHED CASE ON EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE STAYS

Posted by Tristan R. Pettit, Esq. in Caselaw, Emergency Assistance / Comments

We will soon have a published Wisconsin Court of Appeals decision on the issue of emergency assistance stays in eviction actions that will assist us as landlords in removing the non-paying tenant.

Sec. 799.40(4) of the Wisconsin Statutes states that a court must stay an eviction action brought against a tenant that has applied for emergency assistance.  The stay remains in effect until it is determined if the tenant is eligible for the assistance, and if they are, until that assistance is received.  For any of you that have been in this situation you are well aware that this stay can work a substantial hardship on the landlord who is now required to allow a tenant to remain in his/her property for free.  Even if the tenant is eventually awarded the emergency assistance it typically does not cover the full amount of the past due rent owed and as such the landlord declines the money and asks for his/her writ.  The tenant then uses the assistance money for the security deposit on their next apartment.

This stay can delay an eviction for months.  Such a situation is frustrating at best and an improper "taking" of a landlord's property at worse.  In the case of McQuestion v. Crawford (Appeal No. 2008AP1096) from District I (Milwaukee) of the Wisconsin Court of Appeals, it was held that "implicit in the statute's mandate that a stay is required until the tenant receives the emergency assistance is a requirement that the tenant seek and find suitable permanent housing within a reasonable period of time."

What is a "reasonable" amount of time will still need to be determined on a case by case basis by a judge but at least there will now be some required inquiry into the efforts made by the tenant to locate new housing and consideration made for the amount of time that this takes.  Wisconsin landlords now have case law to support our arguments that the length of the stay is no longer reasonable.

Tristan is the Executive Vice President and shareholder with the law firm of Petrie+Pettit and focuses his practice in the area of landlord-tenant law representing landlords and property management companies throughout Wisconsin.